Alternate Universe
St John's defeated Duke 83-82 on February
26th in Cameron. A number of the usual
components were on display for the games
in which Duke has struggled: poor
rebounding, a lack of commitment to team
defense, and problems valuing the ball.
But there was a new, disturbing aspect to
these problems: the two players who had
stepped up all year ran out of gas in the
second half. Shane Battier and Chris
Carrawell were a combined 1-7 in the half,
3-6 from the foul line, and 4 rebounds.
Carrawell also picked up 3 fouls. This is
not to unduly criticize the magnificent
effort they have shown all year, but to
illustrate how much the team needs them.
And yet, Duke had a chance to win against
one of the hottest teams in the country (having
recently beaten Syracuse and crushing
UConn) despite these problems, not to
mention the absence of supersub Mike
Dunleavy? How did Duke get this close? It
was the herculean efforts of Nate James,
a growing-before- our-eyes Jason Williams
and a dominantly confident Carlos Boozer.
The Red Storm have been playing
exceptionally well during an internal
struggle where point guard Erick Barkley
was suspended because of an absurd NCAA
by-law. As a result, Coach K and Shane
Battier asked the Sixth Man to lay off St.
John's and their NCAA woes, because they
were opposed to the particular by-laws.
The Red Storm got among the friendliest
of welcomes any opponent has ever
received in Cameron, with Barkley
actually garnering applause. His actions
after the game did not merit this support,
but more on that in Cameron Craziness.
But St. John's is a team filled with good
ball- handlers, slashers and shooters.
They are, however, very small and the
fact that they beat Duke so handily on
the boards (35-28) and also finessed Duke's
pressure with few problems (only 11
turnovers) did not speak well of Duke's
effort in the hustle category.
St John's showed very early on that they
weren't intimidated by the extremely loud
Cameron surroundings nor the Devils
themselves with an impressive early start.
Marvis "Bootsy" Thornton
started the proceedings by nailing a
three, but was answered by Carrawell on
the next possession. The Red Storm took
an early 7-3 lead, but Duke battled back
to tie the game up at 10 when Matt
Christensen took advantage of good
position and a small SJU frontline. Duke
put together a 17-5 run led by Battier
and James. Nate hit a three and had a
transition dunk on a Carrawell steal,
while Shane simply took the game over,
hitting a couple of very long threes and
a baseline jumper. Cameron was steamy and
rocking, but St John's was not through.
A 9-0 run was stopped only by a Williams
three and Carrawell drive, giving the
Devils a 32-24 lead with about six
minutes left in the half. But St John's
really seized the momentum, once again
closing to within 4. Carrawell got fouled
and the basket counted, but his
problematic foul shooting on the day
started with him missing the free throw.
Battier suddenly started missing threes
and completely abandoned attempting to
drive to the basket. Carrawell was
getting some contact going up with the
ball, but wasn't getting the foul called.
He did not react well to this, because he
kept going to the basket too soft instead
of trying to really force St John's to
foul him. It is worth noting that Duke
only went to the foul line once in the
half, settling too often for jumpers.
Still, Duke led 38-33 with two minutes
left in the half. However, Duke really
bungled the last couple of minutes, which
may have cost them the game. The Devils
took bad shots and turned the ball over,
and St. John's really capitalized,
grabbing a 39-38 halftime lead and giving
themselves a confidence boost.
The first couple of minutes of the second
half saw a number of lead changes, as
Boozer was finally into the game and
giving St. John's problems. Duke took a
47-45 lead when C'well blocked a shot and
then got it back from Williams on the
break for a slam. Some free throws
extended the lead to 5, and things looked
good for Duke. SJU displayed some of
their resiliency and their ability to
shoot from the perimeter (they were 7-14
from three on the day) by tying it up at
50 once again. A Boozer three point play
gave Duke a 53-50 lead, but the Johnnies
went on a 10-0 run to take command. Duke
was reeling as Carrawell looked confused
and no one could buy a shot. The Devils
looked tired and the unthinkable looked
like it was about to occur: a blowout
loss in Cameron.
That was not to be, as two of the frosh
came of age and the less heralded of
Shane Battier's "Three Pillars"
started to dominate. Jason Williams had
blown three straight possessions in the
second half when Duke had a chance to run
when he threw bad passes in 2-on-1
situations. Rather than get down on
himself, he instead worked harder and
started to carve up the Red Storm. The
rally began with a relocation pass from
Boozer to James for a three, and Duke
finally cracked the zone on a nice pass
from Williams to Boozer that cut the lead
to three. St John's upped the lead to 7,
but Williams penetrated and canned a 12'
jumper and then found James for an
emphatic transition dunk. St John's was
still in a solid offensive rhythm and
held Duke off for awhile, but Williams
kept up the pressure with a three and an
alley-oop to Boozer.
Finally, the Devils were able to take
back the lead with back to back threes by
James and Williams with five minutes left.
Williams tore the roof off the joint with
an alley-oop in halfcourt for a
thunderslam by Boozer over two other
players. A free throw later by Boozer
gave Duke a 4 point lead with about three
minutes left, but miscues by Carrawell
and bad shots led to a 81-79 Red Storm
lead with a minute left. James answered
with a huge three with thirty seconds
left to give Duke a one-point lead. Lavor
Postell missed for St. John's, but they
got yet another offensive rebound and
Barkley found the ever- troublesome
Bootsy for a wide-open jumper. Duke still
had ten seconds left. They zipped it
upcourt and found Boozer, but Barkley
slapped it out of his hands with five
seconds left. Carrawell took matters into
his own hands, but got doubleteamed and
took a bad shot. The clock ran out, and
the Red Storm escaped with a hard-earned
win.
This game was obviously played in the
alternate universe where Battier and
Carrawell didn't significantly step up
their scoring and rebounding production
and instead continued to merely be solid
role players. An off game by those two
simply shows just how valuable they've
been all year long, and how well they've
played.
**Negatives:
1. Rebounding. This has been a recording....
Battier, Carrawell and James combined for
9 rebounds. Christensen had 2 in fourteen
minutes of play.
2. Perimeter defense. St. John's was 7-14,
and many of those shots came on wide-open
attempts where Duke did a bad job of
rotating. Duke in general looked
disorganized on defense, missing a number
of switches.
3. Shot selection. The Devils got lulled
into the zone trap. Battier, after a hot
start, lost his confidence after a couple
of misses. Carrawell started short-arming
weak attempts.
** Positives:
1. Passing. Duke had 30 field goals and
25 assists, an astonishing figure. Jason
Williams was brilliant with 13 assists
2. Post offense. Once Boozer got into the
swing of things, he started to dominate.
Christensen and Horvath also had their
moments, but Boozer made 6 of his last 7
shots.
3. Post defense. St John's did most of
their damage from outside, but found it
hard to score down low. Duke had 5 blocks
and Battier came up with a couple of
steals in the post.
Player-By-Player Analysis:
** Boozer: Early on, Carlos was once
again playing very poor defense, as he
did not rotate over and Duke got burned a
couple of times as a result. Coach K
yanked him a couple of times for his lack
of hustle. It didn't help that he missed
some easy shots early on, although he was
trying to finesse his way in instead of
powering his way up over the smaller
Johnnies. Williams did find him for a
couple of baskets in the first half, but
it still wasn't his best effort. He was
obviously given a good talking-to by the
coaches at the half, because he came out
very aggressively in the second half,
first getting fouled and hitting both
foul shots (he was an excellent 7-8 for
the game) and then picking up a loose
ball and laying it in on a break. A
blocked shot led to a break where C'well
scored. He continued to steadily
contribute, getting fouled and hitting
the basket, and later finding Williams
for a three that Duke desperately needed.
On the next play, Williams found him for
yet another three point play. His defense
also picked up as Anthony Glover wasn't
getting a lot of easy shots. He was the
biggest target on Duke's late-game
comeback, laying in an alley-oop and
absolutely bringing the house down with
an awesome thunderslam in traffic. When
he's really into the game, Carlos is a
terrifying force, especially against
shorter teams. St John's had no answer
for him once he got going, but it's
unfortunate that Duke didn't try harder
to penetrate the zone to get Carlos going,
and that Carlos himself was so sluggish
early on.
** Battier: Shane was absolutely on fire
in the first half, and then he
mysteriously turned into a glacier in the
second. For about five minutes, he was
the most dominant player on the floor. He
had a three, a pass to James for a three,
another three, a nice turnaround jumper
on the baseline, and a 25' jumper taken
with absolute confidence. He had 3 boards,
a steal, and a block as well. That,
unfortunately, turned out to be pretty
much it for Shane. He did have a free
throw and a couple of more steals in the
second half, but his shot completely left
him, and he stopped trying to drive for
reasons I can't comprehend. He also only
grabbed just 2 more boards, and was one
of the big reasons why Duke had trouble
blocking out. His energy just wasn't
there, highly unusual for one of the most
energetic players in basketball.
Hopefully, he'll come out firing against
Clemson and attack the basket more.
** Carrawell: Chris had a fine first half
but his collapse in the second was just
inexplicable. After the game, even he was
mystified. He tried to blame fatigue,
having to defend great players and heat,
but then realized that he was just making
excuses. Hopefully, this great warrior
will rebound quickly, because Duke is
dead without him at the top of his game.
He started off the game with a three and
later had a steal and a pass to James for
a dunk. On Duke's next possession, he
found Horvath open for another slam. In
typical C-Well fashion, he had a couple
of drives for baskets at a time when St.
John's was mounting a comeback, though he
did mess up towards the end of the half.
In the second half, his positive
contributions were limited to the first
five minutes, where he had a slam on the
break on two free throws--this after
missing two free throws earlier in the
half. After that, his only impact came on
finding an open James for a three,
because he was stripped on several drives
and played too much one-on-one. He
apparently disregarded an order from K on
the last play to try and make something
happen himself, and it backfired. Chris
deserves the benefit of the doubt because
his decision-making is usually so sound,
but I think the time has come to trust
his younger teammates a bit more. They're
ready, and I think they proved it.
** James: Nate is still recovering from
the flu, which limited some of his
mobility, but he still made an amazing
number of great plays. His defense was
still not quite all the way there,
especially on switches. He showed very
quickly what he was going to do when he
hit a 19' jumper. Soon afterwards, he hit
a three and then zoomed downcourt for a
transition dunk. He hit another jumper
late in the half and was Duke's second
leading scorer with 9. But he didn't have
a single board, which would hurt Duke in
the long run. Nate did come up huge in
the second half, hitting a three that
tied the game at 45 and later finding
Boozer for the basket + 1. But he really
took over in the last nine minutes.
Williams found him for a transition dunk,
and then he hit a three to pull Duke
within 3. His biggest basket came with
thirty seconds left, when Carrawell found
him in the corner for a three, putting
Duke up by 1. Alas, he couldn't grab a
rebound on the other end, and his heroism
was not rewarded. Nate has stepped up
several times this year when the other
veterans weren't playing well, and this
was no exception. Hopefully, he'll be
fully recovered for Clemson and ready to
go all-out on both ends.
** Williams: It's possible that this game
heralded a transition in leadership, with
Williams truly stepping up as the team
decision-maker. When he stepped up and
took over the game with ten minutes left,
you could see him acting instead of
reacting. He knew what to do and did it
well. There was a sense that he could no
longer defer to C'well and Battier, and
needed to do something himself to spark
the team. And not just for one play, but
for the rest of the game. He had a mostly
unremarkable first half, as he looked a
little intimidated by Barkley. He did
have six assists, dishing to Carrawell
and Battier for 3 threes, finding his
roommate Boozer for a couple of inside
buckets and C'well on a drive. He did
have a few drives that ended up in
questionable shots. The first nine
minutes of the second half were also far
from memorable, especially when he made
horrible passes on the break for three
straight turnovers. But when he hit a
three with eleven minutes left, he got a
lot of confidence. He found Boozer for
the basket and the foul, stripped Barkley
a couple of times, fueling a break for
Nate James. He pulled up on one break for
a short jumper that rattled in, and then
popped a three. He really started
clicking with Boozer, throwing a couple
of alley-oops that Boozer converted. His
last basket, however, came with five
minutes left, although it did put Duke up
76-75. Jason played very solid defense on
Barkley, limiting him to 12 points on 14
attempts. Barkley didn't penetrate much
on him, either, and it's one of his
specialties. If Jason can duplicate this
performance in a game where everyone else
is playing well, it will really boost
Duke's chances.
** Horvath: Carrawell found Nick for a
dunk early in the game, but he didn't get
many looks at the basket after that. St
John's covered him well on the perimeter.
He did rebound fairly well and in traffic,
getting 3 in just nine minutes of play.
** Christensen: Matt did a few good
things. He powered over a couple of Red
Stormers for an early basket, and passed
to James for a bucket. He also had a
steal in the second half that helped
ignite a break. He didn't rebound as well
as I had hoped, just getting 2.
Cameron Craziness: This was one of the
finest crowds ever at a Duke game. They
were challenged by both the recent flop
against Maryland and the request by
Battier and Coach K to go easy on Erick
Barkley to root positively for the team.
They had a little anti-NCAA skit before
the game where the NCAA shot down a
student. There were tons of signs for the
players. Mike Dunleavy had a number of
signs for him, including "Mike, we'll
still kiss you" held up by some
female fans. I also liked "Spike Lee
ain't got nothing on us!", a
reference to Lee being at the St. John's
game last year in New York. There was a
"Shane For President" sign,
both a prediction and a celebration of
Shane being elected to the presidency of
the Student Basketball Council, a student-athlete
group dedicated to giving a voice to the
players. Jason had a "Big Williams
Style" poster, and I've read that he
even signed the tent where that slogan
originated. As the St John's players were
introduced, each heard "Fight the
power" after their name, with
Barkley getting applause--a first in
Cameron. During the game, the crowd was
loud and supportive, helping the team out
when they got down by cheering even
louder. When Duke went on their late game
run, the place shook like on very few
other occasions. The Crazies reminded
Bootsy Thornton of his real first name by
taunting "Marvis, Marvis" at
the foul line. When St. John's won,
Barkley ran over to the student section
and taunted them, in a hand-to-his-ear
pose seen in newspapers everywhere.
Reported by Rob Clough, tmc@duke.edu
|